Get to Know Wagner Agency

Meet the team and learn the story behind Pittsburgh's most trusted independent insurance agency since 1941.

How It All Started

Wagner Agency opened its doors in 1941 in Pittsburgh's historic financial district with a simple belief: Pittsburgh families and businesses deserved honest insurance guidance from people who actually knew their names. Too many people were overpaying with carriers that treated them like a number. We set out to change that.



What started as a family business has grown into one of Western Pennsylvania's most trusted independent agencies, serving clients across personal, commercial, and specialty insurance lines. We have added carriers, expanded our team, and deepened our expertise over the decades. But what we are most proud of is the trust our Pittsburgh neighbors place in us every single day. That trust drives everything we do, from the carriers we partner with to the way we pick up the phone.

What We Stand For

Our values are not just words on a wall. They shape every conversation, every policy, and every relationship we build across Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania.

We give you straight answers and unbiased advice, even when it means telling you something you did not expect to hear. Your trust matters more than any commission.

Pittsburgh is more than just our workplace. It is our home, where we raise our families, support our neighbors, and show up when it counts. Protecting this community holds deep personal significance for us.

We do not stop at finding you a policy. We shop the market year after year to make sure your coverage and rates still make sense as your life and business evolve.

Ready to Compare Rates and Save?

Prefer to talk to a real person? Give us a call and we will answer your questions and provide a quote over the phone. No hassle and no hard sell — just honest advice from Pittsburgh's most trusted independent agency.